Validation, Methods & System Performance
Qualisys Miqus

Lights, Cameras, Action – The Influence of Lighting and Camera Position on Walking and Running Kinematic Measurements Using Theia3D Markerless Motion Capture

Journal of Biomechanics
•
2026
•
Original research
Theia3D version:
v2023.1.0.3161, patch 4
More Articles

Study at a glance

In 14 healthy adults walking and running on a treadmill, both room lighting intensity and camera placement significantly affected the joint range-of-motion values Theia3D produced, particularly in the frontal and transverse planes, while the marker-based reference measurements stayed consistent across the same lighting conditions.

Summary

Disclaimer: The following summary details independent academic research. Theia3D is intended for research, sports performance and educational use only. It is not cleared as a medical device and is not intended to be used for the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of any disease, injury or medical condition.

Editor's note: Theia3D version v2023.1.0.3161, patch 4, as stated in the paper.

Study Overview

Design

A within-subject study examining how room lighting intensity and camera placement independently affect joint range-of-motion measurements from Theia3D markerless motion capture during treadmill walking and running, with marker-based motion capture recorded simultaneously as a reference measure.

Participants

Fourteen recreationally active adults (4 women, 10 men; mean age 35 years) free of any musculoskeletal or neurological condition that might affect gait.

Lighting Manipulation

Participants walked (3 km/h) and ran (12 km/h) on a treadmill while room lighting was adjusted, in randomized order, across four intensities (1069, 692, 455, and 289 lux) representing a range of lighting levels seen in real-world markerless capture environments. Both a 14-camera marker-based system and a 12-camera Theia3D system recorded simultaneously at each lighting level, with camera exposure and gain held constant across all conditions to isolate the effect of lighting alone.

Camera Position Manipulation

Using data from a single lighting condition, three camera configurations were recreated post-collection by selectively excluding cameras from the full 12-camera dataset: SURROUND (all 12 cameras, evenly distributed around the capture volume), CORRIDOR (8 cameras, with anterior and posterior cameras removed to simulate a space-restricted, predominantly sagittal-view setup), and FRONTAL (cameras predominantly removed from posterior positions, simulating a setup limited to anteriorly biased views).

Analysis

Lower-limb joint range of motion (ROM) was calculated in all three planes for the hip, knee, and ankle. Two-way repeated-measures ANOVAs assessed the main effects and interaction of lighting condition and motion-capture system (for the lighting analysis) and the main effect of camera position (for the camera-position analysis), with marker-based data serving as the criterion measure throughout.

Key Findings

  • Room lighting significantly affected joint range of motion measured by Theia3D, while marker-based measurements remained stable across the same conditions. Significant lighting-by-system interaction effects were found for sagittal- and frontal-plane hip and knee ROM and transverse-plane knee and ankle ROM during walking, and across all three planes at the hip, knee, and ankle during running; post-hoc testing found no significant lighting-related differences in the marker-based data at either speed.
  • The direction of lighting's effect on Theia3D's measurements was inconsistent across joints, with reduced lighting decreasing measured hip range of motion in some cases while increasing measured knee and ankle range of motion in others, suggesting the underlying tracking mechanism is affected differently depending on the joint and plane of motion.
  • Camera placement significantly affected range of motion at nearly every joint and plane tested during both walking and running. The only range-of-motion values not significantly altered by camera position were transverse-plane ankle ROM during running, sagittal-plane hip ROM during running, and sagittal-plane ankle ROM during walking.
  • The reduced-camera CORRIDOR and FRONTAL setups showed larger deviations from the marker-based reference than the full 12-camera SURROUND setup, with the authors attributing this in part to increased segment occlusion, cameras positioned predominantly in the sagittal plane in the CORRIDOR setup may allow one body segment to occlude another, while the FRONTAL setup's anteriorly biased views could be occluded by the treadmill itself, particularly affecting the ankle joint.
  • Agreement between the two systems was consistently more sensitive to camera placement and lighting in the frontal and transverse planes than in the sagittal plane, a pattern broadly consistent with other work in this space showing markerless tracking tends to be least precise for out-of-plane, rotational joint motion.

What This Means for Movement Science Researchers and Lab Methodologists

For labs planning to deploy Theia3D outside a fully optimized laboratory space, whether due to lower ambient lighting or a constrained number or placement of cameras, this study is a useful reminder that the data-collection environment itself can meaningfully shape the resulting kinematics, independent of the underlying system's capabilities. The authors' core recommendation is practical: when comparing markerless and marker-based systems, or when reporting markerless data collected outside ideal conditions, lighting intensity and camera configuration should be documented as a matter of course, since the level of agreement reported in one study may not transfer directly to a different lighting or camera setup.

The Role of Theia3D in Movement Analysis

Theia3D was the markerless system evaluated throughout this study, processing the same underlying video data under four different lighting conditions and, separately, under three different camera configurations derived from a common 12-camera dataset. This design let the researchers isolate how much of Theia3D's measured kinematic variation was attributable to the data-collection environment itself, independent of any change in the movement being captured, since the marker-based reference data for each trial remained identical across the camera-position comparisons.

Study Limitations and Future Directions

The authors note that camera exposure and gain were deliberately held constant across lighting conditions to isolate lighting's effect in this study, but that real-world practice often involves increasing exposure time and gain to brighten video in lower light, an adjustment that can itself introduce motion blur during faster movements and was not tested here. The study used a treadmill-based protocol, where participants stayed near-stationary relative to the cameras and camera focal length and aperture were individualized to that fixed distance; the authors note this would not directly apply to overground gait analysis, where a moving subject's distance from each camera continuously changes and could further affect tracking. The number of cameras differed between the SURROUND, CORRIDOR, and FRONTAL setups, so differences between them could be partly attributable to camera count rather than position alone. The familiarisation period before data collection was shorter than some prior work has used, which the authors note means absolute kinematic values might not directly translate to other studies, even though the within-study comparisons between camera setups remain valid. The authors identify extending this work to overground gait analysis, and exploring the interaction between room lighting and camera settings together, as clear next steps.

Citation: Thomas, A., Tucker, C. B., Lunn, D. E., Cooke, M. J., Nicholson, G., & Walker, J. (2026). Lights, cameras, action: The influence of lighting and camera position on walking and running kinematic measurements using Theia3D markerless motion capture. Journal of Biomechanics, 203, 113343. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbiomech.2026.113343

Link: Read the full study

Does Your Capture Environment Shape Your Markerless Data More Than You Think?

This study shows that room lighting and camera placement can meaningfully shift the joint kinematics Theia3D produces, a reminder that reported agreement between markerless and marker-based systems is tied to the specific conditions under which it was measured. If your work involves deploying markerless capture outside a fully optimized lab space and you want to understand how lighting and camera setup could affect your own results, talk to our team about getting the most reliable data from your capture environment.

Recent Posts