Study at a glance
Summary
Disclaimer: The following summary details independent academic research. Theia3D is intended for research, sports performance and educational use only. It is not cleared as a medical device and is not intended to be used for the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of any disease, injury or medical condition.
Editor's note: The paper does not report a specific Theia3D software version number. Here, Theia3D served as the markerless motion-capture tool for assessing single-leg squat biomechanics in an ACL reconstruction cohort, rather than as a system being validated against marker-based motion capture within this particular study.
Study Overview
Design
A biomechanical, cross-sectional cohort study (Level 3 evidence) examining the correlation between quadriceps strength symmetry and peak knee flexion symmetry during a single-leg squat test, and comparing lower-extremity biomechanics between two different nonstance-limb standardization methods, in athletes 5 to 7 months after ACL reconstruction.
Participants
Sixty-six competitive or recreational athletes who underwent ACL reconstruction (with either a bone-patellar tendon-bone or quadriceps tendon autograft, including some with a concomitant meniscal repair or meniscectomy) completed testing 5 to 7 months after surgery; participants were strength-matched between groups to minimize confounding from quadriceps strength differences. Exclusion criteria included a contralateral or revision ACL reconstruction, a multiligament knee trauma, an autograft harvested from the contralateral limb, or previous knee surgery on either limb. Based on visual review of their self-selected nonstance-limb position during testing, 33 athletes were grouped into a posterior standardization (PS) group and 33 into a neutral standardization (NS) group; baseline demographic and strength characteristics did not differ significantly between groups.
Data Collection
Following isometric quadriceps strength testing on an isokinetic dynamometer (used to calculate a quadriceps strength limb symmetry index), participants completed a standardized single-leg squat test warm-up followed by three single-leg squats for depth per limb, performed at a self-selected pace on force plates. Movement was captured using 8 synchronized markerless motion capture cameras (Qualisys Miqus, 120 Hz) alongside tri-axial force plates (Bertec). For each participant, Theia3D was used to build a three-dimensional model of each squat trial, and a single representative trial per limb was selected through qualitative review of the Theia3D video for the cleanest execution, free of hesitation or visible correction during the eccentric and concentric phases. Peak knee flexion, joint moments at the hip, knee, and ankle, and change in center of pressure were measured using Theia3D and Qualisys software and analyzed in Visual3D, with joint moment-contribution values calculated at the point of peak knee flexion.
Analysis
Pearson's product-moment correlation examined the linear relationship between quadriceps strength symmetry and peak knee flexion symmetry during the single-leg squat test, separately for the PS and NS groups. Independent-samples t tests (or Mann-Whitney U tests where normality assumptions were violated) were used for within-group comparisons between surgical and nonsurgical limbs and for between-group comparisons of biomechanical variables, with significance set at α = 0.05.
Key Findings
- Standardizing the single-leg squat test with the nonstance limb in the posterior position produced a statistically significant, medium-strength positive correlation between quadriceps strength symmetry and peak knee flexion symmetry (R = 0.37, R² = 0.14, p = 0.01), while standardizing with the nonstance limb in the neutral position produced a weaker, non-significant correlation (R = 0.27, R² = 0.07, p = 0.13).
- In both groups, the surgical limb showed significantly less peak knee flexion (PS, p = 0.02; NS, p = 0.03) and significantly less knee moment-contribution (PS, p = 0.04; NS, p = 0.0001) than the nonsurgical limb, along with significantly more hip moment-contribution (PS, p = 0.03; NS, p = 0.0001), indicating a consistent knee-to-hip loading shift in the surgical limb regardless of standardization method.
- Between standardization groups, the surgical limb's anterior-posterior change in center of pressure was significantly greater with neutral standardization than posterior standardization (3.59 cm vs. 2.16 cm, p = 0.03), and the nonsurgical limb's ankle moment-contribution was significantly greater with posterior standardization than neutral standardization (25.2% vs. 22.1%, p = 0.02), while overall peak knee flexion symmetry did not differ significantly between the two groups (p = 0.67).
- The authors interpret these between-group differences as reflecting two distinct compensatory movement strategies for the surgical limb's reduced knee moment-contribution: the posterior standardization group appeared to shift weight backward and rely more on hip moment-contribution, while the neutral standardization group shifted weight slightly forward and increased load through the hip and ankle.
- The authors conclude that peak knee flexion symmetry during the single-leg squat test may be a comparatively better proxy for quadriceps strength symmetry when the test is standardized with the nonstance limb in the posterior position, and suggest that additional metrics beyond peak knee flexion symmetry should be considered when the test is standardized with the nonstance limb in the neutral position.
What This Means for Movement Science Researchers and ACL Reconstruction Recovery Performance Teams
For researchers and performance staff working with athletes after ACL reconstruction, this study offers a specific, practically useful finding for test-battery design: the way the single-leg squat test is standardized meaningfully changes both how strongly it correlates with quadriceps strength symmetry and the underlying movement strategy athletes use to complete it, meaning programs should be deliberate and consistent about which standardization method they use, particularly if they intend to compare results across different timepoints, athletes, or published literature. The authors' own practical interpretation offers a concrete, specific recommendation: posterior standardization may be preferable for knee-specific performance testing and as a lead-in exercise for horizontal hop progressions, while neutral standardization may better suit programs building toward vertical hop progressions, giving performance teams a clearer basis for selecting and interpreting this test within a broader return-to-activity testing battery.
The Role of Theia3D in Movement Analysis
Theia3D served as the markerless motion-capture tool in this study, used to construct a three-dimensional model of each participant's single-leg squat trials and to help select, through visual review of the captured video, the single most representative trial per limb for detailed biomechanical analysis. This workflow illustrates a practical use case for markerless capture in a working performance and recovery setting: collecting detailed joint kinematic and kinetic data across a sizable cohort of 66 athletes during a bodyweight functional task, without the marker placement and setup burden that a marker-based system would add to an already multi-test assessment battery.
Study Limitations and Future Directions
The authors identify several limitations specific to this study. The biomechanical data cannot account for the effects of muscle co-contraction, biarticular muscle action, or elastic energy storage and return, all of which can influence joint moment calculations. Trial selection relied on a single author's qualitative, visual review of the Theia3D recordings to identify the cleanest trial per limb, introducing a degree of subjective judgment into which data were analyzed. Only sagittal-plane data were analyzed, so the study cannot directly account for the influence of trunk or upper-extremity mechanics on the observed movement patterns, and joint moment-contribution was analyzed only at the single point of peak knee flexion rather than across the full single-leg squat test. The cohort included athletes of varying ages, training levels, and sports, factors that may influence single-leg squat test mechanics but were not separately accounted for in this analysis. The authors also note that this study's group standardization and testing methodology differs from the single-leg squat test studies cited in their introduction and discussion, making direct comparison with previously published data difficult, and that the study's power analysis was based specifically on the peak knee flexion symmetry metric, meaning it may have been underpowered to detect differences in some of the other biomechanical variables reported.
Citation: Solie, B. S., Eggleston, G., Greufe (Schwery), N., Ogbonnaya, U., & Larson, C. M. (2026). Quadriceps strength correlations and biomechanical differences during the single-leg squat test with posterior versus neutral standardization after ACL reconstruction. Sports Health. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1177/19417381261440535
Link: Read the full study
Does Single-Leg Squat Standardization Change How Well It Reflects Quadriceps Strength Symmetry After ACL Reconstruction?
This study of 66 athletes 5 to 7 months after ACL reconstruction uses Theia3D markerless motion capture to show that standardizing the single-leg squat test with the nonstance limb in a posterior position produces a stronger, statistically significant correlation with quadriceps strength symmetry than standardizing with the nonstance limb in a neutral position, with each method eliciting a somewhat different lower-limb loading strategy. If your work involves ACL reconstruction recovery testing or performance research, talk to our team about applying Theia3D to your own studies.