Study at a glance
Summary
Disclaimer: The following summary details independent academic research. Theia3D is intended for research, sports performance and educational use only. It is not cleared as a medical device and is not intended to be used for the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of any disease, injury or medical condition.
Editor's note: this paper does not state a specific Theia3D software version in its methods. Here, Theia3D served as the biomechanical assessment tool for a training-intervention study, rather than as a system being validated against marker-based motion capture within this particular study; the authors themselves note markerless motion capture's precision for very small joint angles and moments as an area warranting further confirmation (see Study Limitations and Future Directions below).
Study Overview
Design
A three-armed, cluster-allocated (team-level), non-randomized intervention study comparing knee biomechanics and sport-performance outcomes among amateur female football players following three months of twice-weekly training with either the Football+ program, the established FIFA 11+ program, or a continued usual warm-up routine (control), with testing at baseline, immediately post-intervention, and after a 10-week no-intervention follow-up period.
Participants
Fifty-seven amateur female football players (mean age 24.3 years) from three German amateur women's teams were enrolled and allocated by team to the Football+ (n=20), 11+ (n=16), or control (n=6) group; 42 players with complete performance and biomechanical datasets were included in the final analysis after dropouts, primarily from the control group.
Data Collection
Following baseline testing, both intervention groups completed their assigned 20-25 minute warm-up program twice weekly over a 12-week period, while the control group continued its usual warm-up routine. Knee biomechanics during single-leg landing and 45-degree cutting tasks were captured using 14 high-speed Qualisys Oqus 4 video cameras (200 Hz) processed through Theia3D, synchronized with two force plates, at baseline and immediately post-intervention. Sport-performance measures, including a 20-meter sprint, countermovement jump, agility test, and dribbling speed test, were assessed at baseline, post-intervention, and after a 10-week no-intervention follow-up period.
Analysis
A repeated-measures analysis of variance examined time and time-by-group interaction effects across knee kinematic and kinetic measures (including knee flexion angle, knee valgus angle and moment, and vertical ground reaction force) during landing and cutting, and across the four sport-performance measures, with follow-up tests used to identify within- and between-group differences.
Key Findings
- Both the Football+ and 11+ programs produced significant improvements in knee biomechanical measures linked to lower knee loading during single-leg landing and cutting, including greater knee flexion and reduced knee valgus, with the control group showing limited change.
- The Football+ program showed consistently larger magnitudes of improvement than the 11+ program across most knee biomechanical measures, with moderate-to-large effect sizes for the Football+ group compared to small-to-moderate effects for the 11+ group.
- Significant improvements in sprinting, agility, and dribbling performance were observed only in the Football+ group; the 11+ group showed inconsistent or no improvement in these measures, while both intervention groups showed significant gains in vertical jump height.
- None of the performance gains observed immediately post-intervention were retained after the 10-week no-intervention follow-up period, for either intervention group, indicating that the observed benefits require continued, regular practice to be maintained.
- The Football+ program devoted close to twice the training volume to plyometric and directional-change drills compared with the 11+ program, which the authors suggest likely contributed to its larger effects on knee biomechanics and performance.
What This Means for Movement Science Researchers and Football Performance and Conditioning Teams
For researchers and conditioning teams working with amateur-level football players, this study offers a specific, practically useful comparison: a warm-up program explicitly designed to combine movement-quality and performance goals produced more consistent biomechanical improvements and additional performance benefits compared with an established, movement-quality-focused program, within the same time commitment. This is a meaningful consideration for amateur programs, where limited training time is frequently cited as a barrier to implementing structured warm-up routines consistently. At the same time, the finding that performance gains were not retained after a 10-week break reinforces that these programs need to be implemented as an ongoing part of training, not a short-term intervention, and the markerless motion-capture approach used here illustrates a practical way for teams to track movement-quality changes over a training intervention without the setup burden of marker-based systems during repeated field-based testing sessions.
The Role of Theia3D in Movement Analysis
Theia3D served as the markerless motion-capture tool for assessing knee biomechanics during landing and cutting tasks before and after a 3-month training intervention in this study, enabling efficient, repeated biomechanical testing across a relatively large group of amateur players in a laboratory setting without the data-collection burden a marker-based approach might add to an already time-intensive training and testing protocol. It was not itself compared against marker-based motion capture within this particular study.
Study Limitations and Future Directions
The authors note several limitations, including unequal group sizes, particularly a small control group, which may limit how well the findings generalize; a study population limited to amateur female players, meaning results may not directly transfer to male or more highly competitive populations; and a focus on biomechanical and performance outcomes without tracking on-field loading-related outcomes directly, so the longer-term relationship between these biomechanical changes and real-world outcomes remains unknown. The authors are also explicit about a limitation specific to their measurement approach: because their kinematic and kinetic analyses relied on markerless motion capture, which, while efficient and non-invasive for field-based data collection, may be less precise than marker-based systems, particularly for very small joint angles and moments, some of their knee kinetic and kinematic findings, especially subtle between-limb differences, should be interpreted with caution. They call for future research with larger groups to evaluate longer-term outcomes, and recommend combining markerless and marker-based motion capture in future work to further confirm these findings.
Citation: Asgari, M., Hägglund, M., Terschluse, B., Sueck, M., Nolte, K., Schmidt, M., & Jaitner, T. (2026). Alterations in knee biomechanics and motor performance following 3 months training with the Football+ and 11+ warm-up programs among amateur female players. A three-armed cluster allocated, non-randomized intervention study. Journal of Exercise Science & Fitness, 24, 200463. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jesf.2026.200463
Link: Read the full study
Does a Dual-Purpose Warm-Up Program Improve Knee Biomechanics and Performance More Than an Established Program?
This study of 42 amateur female football players uses Theia3D markerless motion capture to track knee biomechanics before and after a 3-month warm-up training intervention, finding that a newer, dual-purpose program produced more consistent improvements in knee movement patterns and added performance benefits compared with the established FIFA 11+ program. If your work involves training-intervention research or sport-performance assessment, talk to our team about applying Theia3D to your own studies.