Study at a glance

In 23 healthy young men performing a 90-degree change-of-direction maneuver, Theia3D showed good overall agreement with marker-based motion capture for most trunk and lower-limb joint angles, with systematic differences concentrated in ankle dorsiflexion, knee flexion, and hip external rotation specifically.

Summary

Disclaimer: The following summary details independent academic research. Theia3D is intended for research, sports performance and educational use only. It is not cleared as a medical device and is not intended to be used for the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of any disease, injury or medical condition.

Editor's note: Theia3D version 2023.1.0.3160, as stated in the paper.

Study Overview

Design

A concurrent comparison study evaluating agreement between marker-based and markerless (Theia3D) motion capture for trunk and lower-limb kinematics during a pre-planned 90-degree change-of-direction maneuver.

Participants

Twenty-three healthy young men (age 19.3 years; height 1.74 m; mass 69.8 kg), free of lower-limb musculoskeletal trauma in the prior three months and free of a history of knee surgery such as ACL repair.

Data Collection

After a warm-up including change-of-direction practice, participants ran toward a force plate at a standardized approach speed, guided by a moving LED pacer, made foot contact at its center, and performed a pre-planned 90-degree change of direction away from their supporting leg. Five successful trials were recorded for each participant. Marker-based data were captured using a 12-camera infrared system (200 Hz) with 21 reflective markers, and markerless data were captured simultaneously using 10 Sony RX0 II video cameras (120 Hz) processed through Theia3D.

Analysis

Hip, knee, ankle, and trunk joint angles were calculated for both systems using consistent joint coordinate system definitions in Visual3D. Agreement between systems was assessed using Bland-Altman analysis, intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC), root mean square deviation (RMSD), and normalized root mean square error (NRMSE) across the stance phase of the change-of-direction maneuver.

Key Findings

  • Most joint angles showed good agreement between marker-based and markerless motion capture (ICC greater than 0.75), with trunk kinematics in particular showing excellent reliability, including trunk left rotation (ICC = 0.96) and hip flexion (ICC = 0.94).
  • Three measures showed the largest, most systematic differences between the two systems: ankle dorsiflexion (mean difference of -10.92°), knee flexion (-8.32°), and hip external rotation (12.1°), each considerably larger than the differences found for other joints measured.
  • Ankle supination, ankle abduction, and knee external rotation showed comparatively lower reliability between systems (ICC below 0.75), identifying these as additional specific measures where agreement was weaker.
  • Markerless motion capture showed noticeably smaller measurement variability (standard deviation) than marker-based motion capture for several measures, including knee external rotation and hip external rotation, consistent with prior reports of markerless systems' high trial-to-trial reliability.
  • The authors note that the error magnitudes observed in this study were comparable to those previously reported for walking and running using Theia3D, suggesting the system maintains a practically applicable level of accuracy even for the more biomechanically complex and demanding movement of changing direction.

What This Means for Movement Science Researchers and Multidirectional Sports Performance Teams

For researchers and performance staff working with sports that involve rapid changes of direction, this study offers a specific, practically grounded finding: markerless motion capture can provide kinematic data during this demanding movement category with accuracy broadly comparable to its established performance during walking and running, while trunk kinematics in particular showed strong, consistent agreement with marker-based measurement. The specific, systematic differences identified at the ankle, knee, and hip offer a concrete, actionable caution: teams and researchers relying on these particular joint angles from change-of-direction tasks should account for these known differences when comparing or combining data across marker-based and markerless systems, rather than assuming the two methods are fully interchangeable for every joint and plane of motion measured during this kind of movement.

The Role of Theia3D in Movement Analysis

Theia3D was the markerless motion capture system directly evaluated against marker-based motion capture in this study, specifically for its accuracy and reliability during a sport-specific change-of-direction task, a movement category that had not been thoroughly validated in prior Theia3D research relative to walking, running, and jumping. The study's finding that markerless motion capture produced comparable or even lower trial-to-trial variability than marker-based motion capture for several measures offers a useful, practical point in markerless capture's favor for this kind of fast, demanding athletic movement, where reducing measurement noise matters for detecting genuine differences in performance or technique.

Study Limitations and Future Directions

The authors note that testing was conducted in a controlled laboratory setting with a standardized, restricted approach speed chosen to prioritize participant safety, and that markerless systems are known to be susceptible to motion blur in video images at higher speeds, so it remains unclear whether this same level of accuracy would be maintained during the higher-speed movements typical of actual training or competition. They note that their sample consisted exclusively of young men, so these findings may not generalize to female athletes or other populations who may show different kinematic patterns during change-of-direction maneuvers. Only five trials per participant were analyzed to limit fatigue from the physically demanding task, which may not have captured each participant's typical movement pattern as well as a larger number of repetitions might for a more cyclical movement like walking, given that change-of-direction tasks tend to show more trial-to-trial variation. The two systems also used different criteria to identify the stance phase analyzed, a ground-reaction-force threshold for the marker-based system and a kinematic threshold for the markerless system, which may have introduced an unquantified timing offset between the two systems' analysis windows. The authors identify testing a more diverse range of participants, examining markerless accuracy at higher, more competition-realistic speeds, and further investigating the specific sources of the ankle, knee, and hip differences identified as important next steps.

Citation: Nishikawa, N., Watanabe, S., & Yamamoto, K. (2025). Comparison of kinematics between markerless and marker-based motion capture systems for change of direction maneuvers. Journal of Biomechanics, 192, 112965. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbiomech.2025.112965

Link: Read the full study

Does Markerless Capture Accurately Measure Change-of-Direction Kinematics?

This study of 23 young men finds that Theia3D shows good overall agreement with marker-based motion capture for trunk and lower-limb kinematics during a 90-degree change-of-direction maneuver, with systematic differences concentrated in ankle dorsiflexion, knee flexion, and hip external rotation. If your work involves multidirectional sports performance research, talk to our team about applying Theia3D to your own studies.

Recent Posts