Study at a glance
Summary
Disclaimer: The following summary details independent academic research. Theia3D is intended for research, sports performance and educational use only. It is not cleared as a medical device and is not intended to be used for the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of any disease, injury or medical condition.
Editor's note: Theia3D version v2024.02.1, as stated in the paper.
Study Overview
Design
A field-based, within-subject reliability study establishing the within-session and intersession reliability, and minimal detectable change, of peak knee angles and moments measured by Theia3D markerless motion capture during gait and squatting, recorded before and immediately after a full work shift at participants' own workplace.
Participants
Twenty-one female early childhood educators (mean age 41.6 years; mean employment duration 12.5 years; mean BMI 29.3), all employed full-time at an early learning centre for at least three months, with no diagnosed knee joint condition, no recent non-occupational lower-extremity trauma, and no prior lower-extremity surgical history.
Data Collection
Thirty minutes before, and immediately after, a full work shift, each participant completed gait trials at a self-selected pace and squatting trials on a 4.9-meter platform, squatting as though picking up a standing or seated child, with no constraints on squat depth or foot placement. Segment motion was recorded using eight Qualisys Miqus cameras (85 Hz) and processed through Theia3D (v2024.02.1), while ground reaction forces were recorded using three platform-embedded force plates (425 Hz). Peak knee adduction angle, knee flexion angle, knee adduction moment, and knee flexion moment were extracted separately for each participant's dominant and non-dominant leg from the first two usable trials of each task and session.
Analysis
Within-session reliability (consistency between two trials in the same session) and intersession reliability (consistency between the pre-shift and post-shift sessions) were each assessed using a two-way random-effects intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) for absolute agreement, with ICC values of 0.75 or greater considered acceptable. Minimal detectable change (MDC) was calculated from the standard error of measurement for each outcome, and an established 5-degree MDC threshold from the gait literature was used to interpret whether angle-based MDC values were within a range still considered practically useful.
Key Findings
- Within-session reliability for peak knee angles ranged from poor to excellent during gait (ICC 0.24 to 0.94) and from moderate to excellent during squatting (ICC 0.52 to 0.99), with squatting generally showing more consistent, repeatable measurements than gait for several specific outcomes, a pattern opposite to the study's initial hypothesis that squatting's non-cyclic movement pattern would reduce reliability relative to gait.
- Intersession reliability was moderate to excellent for gait (ICC 0.59 to 0.96) but ranged more widely, from poor to excellent, for squatting (ICC 0.05 to 0.96), indicating that consistency between the pre-shift and post-shift sessions was generally more dependable for gait than for squatting.
- Minimal detectable change values for peak knee angles and moments ranged from 1.6 to 9.9 degrees and 0.09 to 0.84 Nm/kg for gait, and from 3.7 to 10.2 degrees and 0.05 to 0.24 Nm/kg for squatting. Squat peak knee flexion and adduction angles specifically exceeded the study's 5-degree interpretive threshold, meaning a larger observed difference is needed before it can be confidently interpreted as a real change rather than measurement variability for those squat-specific outcomes.
- The hypothesis that post-shift measurements would show reduced reliability and higher minimal detectable change, reflecting the physical demands of a full work shift, was largely inconclusive. Only a small number of specific outcomes (dominant-leg gait moments and squat knee adduction angles) showed lower within-session reliability post-shift, and changes in gait MDC values varied inconsistently in direction and magnitude between limbs.
- Knee moment outcomes showed consistently poorer intersession reliability than knee angle outcomes across both gait and squatting, with no knee adduction moment measures reaching acceptable intersession reliability for either task, underscoring that angle-based measures were considerably more dependable across sessions than moment-based measures in this field setting.
What This Means for Movement Science Researchers and Occupational Health Teams
For researchers and practitioners studying knee loading in physically demanding occupations, this study offers a specific, practically useful benchmark: Theia3D's peak knee angle measurements showed generally acceptable reliability for both gait and squatting when recorded directly in a workplace setting, but the minimal detectable change values established here, particularly the 5-degree-plus thresholds found for squat knee angles, should inform how large an observed change needs to be before it's interpreted as a genuine shift in an individual's knee mechanics rather than normal measurement variability. The finding that knee moment outcomes were considerably less reliable across sessions than knee angle outcomes is also a useful caution for teams planning to track moment-based outcomes specifically, suggesting angle-based measures may currently be the more dependable choice for field-based, repeated-measures knee assessment with this kind of setup.
The Role of Theia3D in Movement Analysis
Theia3D was the markerless motion capture system evaluated throughout this study, used to establish reliability and minimal detectable change benchmarks for knee mechanics measured directly in an occupational field setting rather than a controlled laboratory. Because this study assessed Theia3D's own measurement consistency rather than comparing it against a marker-based reference, it offers a different, complementary kind of evidence: a practical foundation for researchers and occupational health teams who want to know not just whether Theia3D's measurements agree with marker-based motion capture, but how much a repeated measurement can be expected to vary on its own, in the kind of real-world, non-laboratory setting where markerless capture's practical advantages matter most.
Study Limitations and Future Directions
The authors note that recording in a real workplace rather than a controlled laboratory, while a meaningful strength for ecological validity, also introduced space and camera-angle restrictions that resulted in missing segment data for some trials, particularly at the bottom of the squat movement, where self-occlusion was more likely. This led to the exclusion of enough squat trials that only thirteen of the twenty-one participants had two usable squat trials available for the squat-specific analyses, and using only two trials per outcome may have increased sensitivity to random measurement error. An a priori power calculation indicated a minimum sample size of 28 participants would have been needed for the study's full statistical aims, so the achieved sample size of 21 (and 13 for some squat analyses) may have reduced statistical power and affected the reliability and minimal-detectable-change estimates reported. The study did not directly measure or account for potential fatigue effects between the pre-shift and post-shift sessions, which could have contributed to some of the session-to-session differences observed. Because all participants in this study had physically demanding occupations as early childhood educators, these findings may not generalize to a broader, less physically demanding healthy adult population. The authors identify extending this reliability and minimal-detectable-change framework to additional occupational postures and developing population-specific normative values across other physically demanding professions as clear next steps.
Citation: Hallman, S. M. J., Peckett, K. H., & Acker, S. M. (2026). Reliability and minimal detectable change of knee mechanics during gait and squatting, using markerless motion capture in the workplace. Gait & Posture, 130, 110266. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gaitpost.2026.110266
Link: Read the full study
How Reliable Is Markerless Knee Assessment in a Real Workplace?
This study establishes reliability and minimal detectable change benchmarks for Theia3D knee angle and moment measurements recorded directly at an occupational worksite, finding generally acceptable reliability for knee angles alongside specific minimal-detectable-change thresholds for interpreting squat knee angle changes. If your work involves assessing knee mechanics in physically demanding occupations and you want to understand how to interpret repeated field-based measurements, talk to our team about applying Theia3D to your own occupational health research.