Study at a glance

In 26 ice hockey goaltenders, Theia3D-based markerless motion capture found that the butterfly and reverse vertical horizontal stances, two of the sport's most common modern goaltending techniques, involved greater hip internal rotation and ankle external rotation than more traditional stances, along with significant side-to-side asymmetries between the blocker and catcher limbs across all stances and joints measured.

Summary

Disclaimer: The following summary details independent academic research. Theia3D is intended for research, sports performance and educational use only. It is not cleared as a medical device and is not intended to be used for the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of any disease, injury or medical condition.

Editor's note: The paper does not report a specific Theia3D software version number. Here, Theia3D served as the motion-capture tool for a research question about goaltending technique, rather than as a system being validated against marker-based motion capture within this particular study.

Study Overview

Design

A cross-sectional biomechanical study quantifying three-dimensional hip, knee, and ankle joint kinematics across four key goaltending stances in ice hockey goaltenders, with a secondary analysis of side-to-side symmetry between the blocker-side and catcher-side limbs.

Participants

Twenty-six active ice hockey goaltenders (age 19.5 years), currently playing at least once per week, aged 16 to 25, with no current hip or groin concern limiting participation, and excluded for a history of lower-extremity or back surgery, a lower-extremity concern other than the hip or groin, a back concern, or a concussion within the prior six months.

Data Collection

Participants performed a series of goaltending stances on a custom slide board while wearing knee pads and hockey socks, holding each posture for three seconds: the butterfly, the standing ready position, the reverse vertical horizontal (RVH) post-play, and the vertical horizontal (VH) post-play, with post-play stances performed and recorded separately for both the blocker side (glove hand holding the stick) and the catcher side (glove hand used to catch pucks). Movement was captured using eight synchronized Sony RX0 II cameras (120 Hz) processed through Theia3D.

Analysis

Hip, knee, and ankle joint angles were calculated for each stance and averaged across the duration of each static trial. Differences in joint angles across the six comparison conditions (butterfly, standing ready, RVH post-side, RVH net-side, VH post-side, VH net-side) were assessed using repeated-measures analysis of variance or Friedman tests, depending on the data's distribution, with blocker-side and catcher-side limb symmetry for each stance assessed as a secondary outcome using paired comparisons.

Key Findings

  • The butterfly and reverse vertical horizontal stances showed higher mean hip internal rotation (16.6° and 22.2°, respectively) than the standing ready and vertical horizontal stances (5.2° and 11.4°, respectively).
  • The butterfly and reverse vertical horizontal stances also showed higher mean ankle external rotation (11.7° and 15.9°, respectively) than the standing ready and vertical horizontal stances (-1.6° and -10.8°, respectively).
  • Compared with the standing ready position, the three kneeling-based stances (vertical horizontal, butterfly, and reverse vertical horizontal) all showed higher mean knee abduction (ranging from 12.4° to 15.1°, versus 5.6° in standing ready) and higher knee external rotation (ranging from 13.0° to 21.3°, versus 0.7° in standing ready).
  • Significant asymmetries between the blocker-side and catcher-side limbs were found across all joints and tasks examined.
  • The authors conclude that the butterfly and reverse vertical horizontal stances, the two most prevalent techniques in modern goaltending, show kinematic patterns consistent with those previously associated with common hip, knee, and ankle loading concerns in goaltenders.

What This Means for Movement Science Researchers and Ice Hockey Goaltending Performance Teams

For researchers and performance staff working with ice hockey goaltenders, this study offers a specific, practically grounded finding: the modern butterfly and reverse vertical horizontal stances involve measurably different, and by several measures more demanding, hip, knee, and ankle kinematics than more traditional standing stances, giving coaches and support staff a concrete biomechanical basis for understanding why these widely adopted techniques are associated with elevated loading concerns at these joints. The significant blocker-side versus catcher-side asymmetries found across every stance and joint examined also offer a specific, practical consideration for goaltender-focused conditioning and monitoring: because a goaltender's two sides are not biomechanically interchangeable during these stances, side-specific assessment and training may be a valuable addition to general goaltending-focused conditioning programs.

The Role of Theia3D in Movement Analysis

Theia3D served as the markerless motion-capture tool in this study, enabling detailed three-dimensional joint kinematic measurement of goaltending-specific stances performed on specialized equipment (a custom slide board) in full goaltending gear, a setup that would present practical challenges for a marker-based approach given the gear, padding, and floor-contact positions involved in these movements. It was not itself compared against marker-based motion capture within this particular study.

Study Limitations and Future Directions

An important note on this summary: the version of this paper available for review was limited to its title, abstract, introduction, and methods sections; the full results, discussion, limitations, and funding/disclosure sections were not available in the source material used to prepare this summary. The Key Findings above reflect the quantitative results reported in the paper's own abstract and key points, but a fuller account of the specific blocker-side versus catcher-side asymmetries, statistical significance values, and the authors' own discussion of limitations could not be confirmed from the available material. Readers interested in the complete statistical results and discussion should consult the full published article directly.

Citation: Harrington, M. S., & Burkhart, T. A. (2026). Lower-extremity kinematics during ice hockey goaltender stances. Journal of Applied Biomechanics. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1123/jab.2025-0285

Link: Read the full study

How Do Modern Goaltending Stances Affect Hip, Knee, and Ankle Biomechanics?

This study of 26 ice hockey goaltenders uses Theia3D markerless motion capture to show that the butterfly and reverse vertical horizontal stances involve greater hip internal rotation, ankle external rotation, and knee abduction than more traditional standing stances, along with significant side-to-side asymmetries between the blocker and catcher limbs. If your work involves ice hockey or goaltending performance research, talk to our team about applying Theia3D to your own studies.

Recent Posts