Study at a glance
Summary
Disclaimer: The following summary details independent academic research. Theia3D is intended for research, sports performance and educational use only. It is not cleared as a medical device and is not intended to be used for the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of any disease, injury or medical condition.
Editor's note: Theia3D version 2022.1.0.2309, as stated in the paper. This study assessed Theia3D's own between-day reliability, rather than comparing it directly against marker-based motion capture within the same test session; a separate, smaller group of participants was tested with marker-based motion capture using an identical protocol as a point of comparison, rather than as a simultaneous, head-to-head validation.
Study Overview
Design
A between-day reliability study assessing trunk and lower-limb kinematics during a single-leg squat and two single-leg landing tasks (forward and medial) using markerless motion capture, with a secondary, separately recruited comparison group assessed using an identical protocol with marker-based motion capture.
Participants
Nineteen recreational athletes (age 27.4 years; height 176.5 cm; mass 73.6 kg), active in sports including football, running, rugby, and basketball, were included in the markerless motion capture analysis. A separate group of 10 participants with similar characteristics was assessed using marker-based motion capture for comparison.
Data Collection
Participants completed two testing sessions one week apart. In each session, participants performed a single-leg squat to a self-selected depth over a controlled 5-second count, a single-leg forward hop landing, and a single-leg medial (sideways) hop landing, with five trials of each task performed on both legs. Markerless motion capture was recorded using eight Qualisys Miqus video cameras (100 Hz) processed through Theia3D; the separate marker-based comparison group was assessed using a 10-camera Qualisys marker-based system with an identical testing protocol.
Analysis
Reliability was assessed using full movement-curve analysis (root mean square difference and statistical parametric mapping) and discrete-point analysis at key moments (initial contact and peak knee flexion) using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) and standard error of measurement (SEM), comparing kinematic measures between the two testing sessions one week apart. The same analysis approach was applied separately to the marker-based comparison group's data.
Key Findings
- Markerless motion capture showed low mean error across full movement curves for all joints and planes in both the single-leg squat (3.6°) and the landing tasks (forward landing 3.2°; medial landing 3.4°).
- Discrete-point analysis showed moderate-to-good reliability between test sessions (ICC of 0.77 for the single-leg squat, 0.83 for forward landing, and 0.80 for medial landing) with low measurement error (SEM of 2.3° to 3.1° across tasks).
- Hip flexion was the one measure that consistently exceeded the 5-degree error threshold across all three tasks and in both markerless and marker-based motion capture, reflecting a broader pattern of greater hip measurement variability seen elsewhere in markerless validation research.
- The separate marker-based comparison group showed slightly higher average error (RMSD of 4.2° for the single-leg squat, 3.5° for forward landing, and 3.3° for medial landing) than markerless motion capture, with marker-based ICC values indicating good reliability overall (0.88 to 0.90).
- The authors conclude that Theia3D markerless motion capture can reliably measure these single-leg tasks with error levels comparable to, and in several comparisons slightly lower than, marker-based motion capture using an identical protocol, supporting confidence in using markerless capture for regular athlete monitoring.
What This Means for Movement Science Researchers and Athlete Monitoring and Screening Teams
For researchers and performance staff responsible for regularly screening or monitoring athletes, this study offers a specific, practically important finding: Theia3D's between-day measurement error for single-leg squat and landing tasks was low and broadly comparable to marker-based motion capture, supporting its use for exactly the kind of frequent, repeated testing that marker-based systems' time and setup demands often make impractical across whole squads or training groups. Because reliable measurement is what allows a genuine change in an athlete's movement pattern to be distinguished from simple day-to-day measurement noise, this finding offers teams a specific, quantified basis, expressed in the SEM and minimal detectable change values reported in the full study, for interpreting whether a change observed during single-leg screening reflects a meaningful shift in movement quality or just typical measurement variability. The one consistent exception, hip flexion, is a useful, specific caution: teams relying on hip flexion measurements from single-leg tasks for screening purposes should build in some additional margin for day-to-day measurement variability at that specific joint.
The Role of Theia3D in Movement Analysis
Theia3D served as the markerless motion capture tool directly assessed for its own between-day measurement reliability in this study, specifically for single-leg squat and landing tasks that have not previously been evaluated for reliability using this system. The study's inclusion of a parallel, separately recruited marker-based reliability comparison offers useful context for interpreting Theia3D's reliability findings, showing that its between-day error levels for these specific tasks sit within the same general range as marker-based motion capture tested under an identical protocol, even though the two groups were not tested simultaneously or compared head-to-head within the same session.
Study Limitations and Future Directions
The authors note that testing was conducted in a controlled laboratory setting, which may not reflect the real-world environments where this technology might ultimately be used to screen athletes, though they caution that moving testing outside a lab setting could introduce its own challenges for controlling how consistently a task is performed. They note that their findings are specific to the Theia3D software and may not directly transfer to other markerless motion capture approaches, given the current lack of comparable reliability research using other pose-estimation methods for these specific single-leg tasks. Because the markerless and marker-based comparisons involved different participants tested in separate samples rather than the same individuals tested simultaneously, any difference in participant characteristics between the two groups could have influenced the comparison, even though the authors aimed to recruit similar participants and use an identical protocol for both. The study also only examined single-leg squat and landing tasks performed at a controlled, submaximal level; running and cutting tasks, also relevant to lower-limb loading in multidirectional sports, were not examined. The authors identify extending this kind of reliability research to other movement tasks such as running and cutting, and further comparing Theia3D directly against other markerless motion capture methods, as important next steps.
Citation: Yoma, M., Herrington, L., Starbuck, C., Llurda, L., & Jones, R. (2025). Between-day reliability of kinematic variables using markerless motion capture for single-leg squat and single-leg landing tasks. International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy, 20(8), 1160-1175. https://doi.org/10.26603/001c.141870
Link: Read the full study
How Reliable Is Markerless Motion Capture for Repeated Single-Leg Screening?
This study of 19 recreational athletes finds that Theia3D markerless motion capture showed low measurement error and moderate-to-good between-day reliability for single-leg squat and landing tasks, comparable to marker-based motion capture using an identical protocol. If your work involves athlete monitoring or movement screening, talk to our team about applying Theia3D to your own screening protocols.