Study at a glance
Summary
Disclaimer: The following summary details independent academic research. Theia3D is intended for research, sports performance and educational use only. It is not cleared as a medical device and is not intended to be used for the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of any disease, injury or medical condition.
Editor's note: Theia3D version 2022.1.0.2309, as stated in the paper. Here, Theia3D served as the markerless motion-capture tool for a research question about adolescent tackle technique, rather than as a system being validated against marker-based motion capture within this particular study; the authors cite prior published Theia3D validation research, including joint-center accuracy and segment-angle agreement figures against marker-based capture, to support their use of the system.
Study Overview
Design
A field-based, cross-sectional biomechanical study examining the effects of tackle height (regular versus low) and shoulder side (dominant versus non-dominant) on three-dimensional trunk, neck, hip, knee, and ankle angles and approach velocity during front-on tackles in adolescent rugby players.
Participants
Fifteen male amateur rugby players (14.86 ± 0.77 years), recruited from an amateur or semi-professional rugby academy, who actively participated in at least one rugby training session per week; participants were excluded for any current musculoskeletal trauma, a history of concussion or head trauma within the prior six months, a neurological condition affecting motor control or balance, a cardiovascular condition that would contraindicate moderate physical exertion, a diagnosed psychological condition that participation might exacerbate, or prior musculoskeletal or neurological surgery within the previous six months.
Data Collection
Participants performed a 2-meter run-up into a tackle bag under four randomized conditions, regular-height dominant shoulder, low-height dominant shoulder, regular-height non-dominant shoulder, and low-height non-dominant shoulder, completing two trials per condition (eight tackles total per participant) after a practice attempt. A marker placed at each participant's greater-trochanter height divided the tackle bag into regular and low contact zones. Movement was captured using eight synchronized Sony RX0-II video cameras (1280x720 pixels, 120 Hz) mounted on tripods and networked to a central laptop. Video data were processed using Theia3D to generate each participant's full-body model, a single pelvis-rooted kinematic chain of 19 segments, which was exported as C3D files and imported into Visual3D for kinematic processing. Thirteen dependent variables were extracted at the instant of contact with the tackle bag, covering trunk segment and joint angles, neck joint angles, hip, knee, and ankle flexion, and center-of-mass forward velocity.
Analysis
Linear mixed-effects models, with tackling type as a fixed effect and a subject-specific random intercept to account for repeated measures within participants, were used to test differences in joint angles and center-of-mass velocity across the four tackle conditions. Significant main effects were followed by pairwise comparisons between tackle types using Bonferroni adjustment, with effect sizes reported as Cohen's d.
Key Findings
- Lowering the tackle target height significantly increased trunk segment flexion by 16.4° and neck flexion by 7.1° at the instant of contact, regardless of which shoulder was used to make the tackle.
- The largest postural change occurred when a low target was combined with the non-dominant shoulder: trunk segment flexion increased by 29.1° and neck flexion by 10.2° compared with a regular-height tackle made with the dominant shoulder.
- Hip flexion increased by approximately 20° during low tackles, while knee flexion and ankle angle showed no statistically significant changes across the four tackle conditions after adjustment for multiple comparisons, and approach speed (center-of-mass velocity) remained consistent across all tackle types.
- Side-to-side differences in trunk and neck posture attributable to shoulder dominance alone were small to trivial (effect sizes of 0.08 to 0.12 between the two low-tackle conditions), suggesting minimal shoulder-side asymmetry in this adolescent sample and a potential opportunity for coaches to consolidate bilateral tackling proficiency before players form long-term one-sided habits.
- The authors note this pattern contrasts with prior research in adult rugby players, which has typically reported a dominant-shoulder preference reflected in tackling success rates and impact characteristics rather than in trunk flexion specifically, suggesting that a strong side preference for tackle posture may develop later with age and exposure rather than being present at this adolescent stage.
- The authors conclude that target height, not shoulder dominance, was the primary driver of tackle posture in this sample, and that adolescent players responding to a low target by folding through the trunk, rather than achieving a lower body position through greater hip and knee flexion, may make it harder to maintain a head-up, eyes-up tackling posture.
What This Means for Movement Science Researchers and Youth Rugby Performance and Coaching Teams
For researchers and coaching staff working with adolescent rugby players, this study offers a specific, practically actionable finding: when coaches cue a lower tackle target, players in this age group tend to respond primarily by folding through the trunk and neck rather than lowering their body position through greater hip and knee flexion, a strategy that may make it harder to maintain the head-up, head-to-the-side posture associated with safer tackling outcomes. This gives coaches a concrete, specific technical cue to reinforce during low-tackle practice, emphasizing level change through the hips and knees rather than trunk folding, and the study's finding of only trivial shoulder-side asymmetry in this adolescent sample suggests an early developmental window where bilateral tackle proficiency could be consolidated through practice on both shoulders before a dominant-side preference becomes established.
The Role of Theia3D in Movement Analysis
Theia3D served as the markerless motion-capture tool in this study, enabling detailed three-dimensional kinematic measurement of a fast, full-contact tackling action performed in full training gear against a tackle bag, a setup that would present practical challenges for a marker-based approach given the physical contact, equipment, and crash-mat landing surface involved. The authors cite prior published Theia3D validation research, including reported joint-center accuracy of under 1 cm and under 3°, lower-limb segment-angle agreement within 5.5° root-mean-square deviation against marker-based capture, and mean sagittal-plane differences of approximately 3° with intraclass correlation coefficients above 0.80 (highest for hip and knee flexion-extension), to support confidence in the measurements used here.
Study Limitations and Future Directions
The authors note several limitations specific to this study. Tackle-bag trials at fixed target heights improve experimental control but limit ecological validity relative to live, opponent-based tackling, where a ball carrier can adapt their movement in response to the tackler; a single marker at the greater-trochanter height was used to divide the regular and low contact zones with no exclusion buffer between them, and the authors suggest a neutral buffer zone of roughly 10 to 15 cm in future research to provide cleaner separation between conditions. Body segment angles were extracted only at the instant of contact, which may not capture pre-contact strategies such as knee or hip flexion adopted earlier in the approach; the authors recommend future research examine the full pre-contact window using continuous kinematic analysis methods. The study sample comprised adolescent males from a single developmental pathway and a fairly narrow age range, limiting the generalizability of the findings across different maturational stages and to female players; the authors call for future studies to recruit younger, more diverse cohorts, including female players, and to incorporate strength and bilateral skill assessments to determine whether critical periods exist for acquiring tackle mechanics on both shoulders.
Citation: Edgington, H. C. A., Liew, B. X. W., Gholami, B., Barrett, M., Edgington, W. S. D., & Moran, J. (2026). Rugby tackle kinematics in adolescent players: effects of tackle height and shoulder side. Sports Biomechanics. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1080/14763141.2026.2689501
Link: Read the full study
How Do Tackle Height and Shoulder Side Affect Tackling Posture in Adolescent Rugby Players?
This study of 15 adolescent male rugby players uses Theia3D markerless motion capture to show that lowering the tackle target height, far more than which shoulder is used, drives greater trunk and neck flexion at the point of contact, with the largest postural change occurring when a low target is combined with the non-dominant shoulder. If your work involves youth rugby technique coaching or contact-sport biomechanics research, talk to our team about applying Theia3D to your own studies.