Study at a glance

In 15 recreational runners, Theia3D showed a clear, systematic bias in the frontal plane at the ankle during running, consistently underestimating eversion and overestimating inversion compared to marker-based motion capture, a discrepancy the authors found persisted even after reprocessing the data with an updated software version.

Summary

Disclaimer: The following summary details independent academic research. Theia3D is intended for research, sports performance and educational use only. It is not cleared as a medical device and is not intended to be used for the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of any disease, injury or medical condition.

Editor's note: Theia3D version v2025.1.0, as stated in the paper. The paper does not name a specific camera brand/model for the markerless system; it reports only that an 8-camera markerless system was used.

Study Overview

Design

A concurrent comparison of frontal-plane subtalar joint kinematics between marker-based and markerless (Theia3D) motion capture during treadmill running at three speeds, using previously collected data reprocessed with an updated Theia3D software version.

Participants

Fifteen recreational runners (7 women, 8 men; mean age 24 years) free of neuromuscular or musculoskeletal differences affecting their movement, whose data had been collected as part of an earlier study by the same research group.

Data Collection

Participants ran on an instrumented treadmill at three speeds (2.24, 2.91, and 3.58 meters per second) for two minutes each, with the final 30 seconds of each speed used for analysis. Movement was captured simultaneously by an 8-camera marker-based reference system using reflective markers and an 8-camera markerless system, with the markerless video data reprocessed using an updated Theia3D software version specifically for this study.

Analysis

Subtalar joint angle, angular velocity, and angular acceleration in the frontal plane were compared between the two systems across the full running stride cycle using statistical parametric mapping, and specifically during the impact phase using repeated-measures analysis of variance for peak angle, range of motion, and peak angular velocity. The researchers also compared the updated-version markerless results against those from an earlier Theia3D software version used in the original data collection to assess whether the software update affected the pattern of discrepancies observed.

Key Findings

  • The markerless system showed a systematic bias in the frontal plane: during a substantial portion of the stride cycle, it reported subtalar joint inversion where the marker-based system reported the physiologically expected eversion, a discrepancy evident across all three running speeds tested.
  • Across all three speeds, the markerless system showed a smaller subtalar joint range of motion and a slower peak eversion angular velocity during the impact phase compared to the marker-based system, consistent with the markerless system underestimating eversion magnitude throughout the running stride.
  • Reprocessing the original dataset with an updated Theia3D software version did not meaningfully change this frontal-plane discrepancy: the researchers found the ensemble movement curves from the updated version closely overlapped with those from the earlier version, indicating this specific limitation has persisted across at least one recent software update rather than already being resolved.
  • Faster running speeds were associated with greater subtalar joint range of motion and peak eversion velocity regardless of which system was used, indicating both systems detected the expected speed-related increase in frontal-plane ankle motion, even though their absolute values differed.
  • The authors note that similar comparison research has reported meaningfully larger differences between markerless and marker-based systems in the frontal plane than in the sagittal plane for subtalar joint measurement specifically, and that other markerless pose-estimation approaches beyond Theia3D have shown comparable frontal-plane limitations, suggesting this may reflect a broader challenge for markerless technology in this specific plane of motion rather than one unique to this particular system.

What This Means for Movement Science Researchers and Running Biomechanics Teams

For researchers and teams working on running biomechanics, this study offers an important, specific caution alongside its broader support for markerless capture's convenience: frontal-plane subtalar joint measurements from Theia3D should currently be interpreted carefully, particularly for applications like evaluating overuse risk, chronic ankle instability, or footwear-related decisions where the direction and magnitude of ankle eversion and inversion carry direct practical weight. The authors are clear that this is a specific, plane-dependent limitation rather than a broader failure of markerless capture, noting that sagittal-plane running measurements have shown considerably stronger agreement with marker-based systems in prior research, and that markerless capture's practical advantages, including portability and ease of data collection outside a dedicated laboratory, remain valuable for running research more broadly. Teams whose work depends specifically on frontal-plane ankle or subtalar joint accuracy should weigh this finding carefully and consider pairing markerless assessment with additional context or marker-based confirmation where that specific measurement is central to the question being asked.

The Role of Theia3D in Movement Analysis

Theia3D was the markerless motion capture system directly evaluated in this study, compared against a marker-based reference system specifically for its accuracy in measuring frontal-plane subtalar joint motion during running, a plane of motion the authors identify as having received comparatively less research attention than sagittal-plane running measurement. The study's additional step of reprocessing the same dataset with an updated software version to test whether the discrepancy had improved is a useful, direct illustration of how markerless technology can be re-evaluated as it evolves, and in this case, provides clear evidence that this particular frontal-plane limitation has not yet been resolved by recent updates.

Study Limitations and Future Directions

The authors note that this study was conducted in a controlled treadmill laboratory setting without ground reaction force or kinetic data, which limits how directly these specific findings extend to overground running or to broader, force-related aspects of running mechanics. They note that marker-based motion capture itself carries known limitations, particularly soft-tissue artifact at the foot, and that careful heel-marker placement is required to avoid introducing its own error into the frontal-plane comparison. The authors attribute the markerless system's frontal-plane limitation primarily to training-data imbalances in the underlying model, which they suggest may be weighted more heavily toward sagittal-plane movement than frontal- or transverse-plane motion, and they explicitly call for future markerless model development to place more balanced emphasis across all three movement planes. They identify extending this kind of plane-specific validation research to overground running, a broader range of running populations, and running-related overuse concerns specifically as important next steps, and recommend that all markerless research explicitly report the specific software version used to support comparison across studies as the technology continues to evolve.

Citation: Tang, H., Munkasy, B., & Li, L. (2026). Markerless motion capture affects talocrural joint frontal plane interpretation. Gait & Posture, 125, 110107. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gaitpost.2026.110107

Link: Read the full study

Does Markerless Capture Accurately Measure Frontal-Plane Ankle Motion During Running?

This study of 15 recreational runners finds that Theia3D shows a systematic, persistent bias in frontal-plane subtalar joint measurement during running, underestimating eversion and overestimating inversion compared to marker-based motion capture, even after an updated software version. If your work involves running biomechanics research and you want to understand where markerless capture currently stands for frontal-plane ankle measurement, talk to our team about applying Theia3D to your own research.

Recent Posts