Study at a glance

In 11 healthy adults and children, Theia3D markerless motion capture showed strong agreement with a marker-based CAST model for hip and knee flexion, with hip rotation, knee rotation, and foot progression standing out as the measures where the two systems tracked together the least.

Summary

Disclaimer: The following summary details independent academic research. Theia3D is intended for research, sports performance and educational use only. It is not cleared as a medical device and is not intended to be used for the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of any disease, injury or medical condition.

Editor's note: Theia3D version not specified in the abstract. The abstract also does not state a camera brand or model for the Theia3D markerless system specifically; only the marker-based system's cameras (Qualisys Oqus) are named in the source text.

Study Overview

Design

A concurrent, within-subject comparison in which Theia3D markerless and a marker-based system (CAST model) recorded the same overground walking trials simultaneously, in healthy adults and children.

Participants

Twelve healthy subjects: seven adults aged 27 to 61 (one man, six women) and five children and adolescents aged 8 to 15 (three boys, two girls). One adult's data was excluded due to extreme markerless-tracking artefacts, leaving 11 subjects in the reported comparison.

Data Collection

Eight Theia3D video cameras were synchronized with an existing 11-camera marker-based (Qualisys Oqus) system already in place in the lab. Subjects walked barefoot overground at a self-selected pace; marker-based kinematics used the CAST model. Each subject completed one static calibration trial and six walking trials, sampled at 50 Hz.

Analysis

Lower-body 3D kinematics were estimated separately from the Theia3D and marker-based (Visual3D) data for each gait cycle. Gait cycles were time-normalized to 101 points, and root mean square error (RMSE) and Pearson's correlation coefficient were calculated between the two systems for each joint angle, on both sides.

Key Findings

  • Hip and knee flexion, and ankle dorsiflexion, showed the strongest agreement between systems. Hip flexion (RMSE 6.69°, correlation 0.98) and knee flexion (RMSE 5.37°, correlation 0.98) both showed very high correlation between the two systems, as did ankle dorsiflexion (RMSE 2.98°, correlation 0.97).
  • Hip rotation showed the weakest agreement of any measure. RMSE reached 10.12° with a correlation of just 0.37, which the authors tie to markerless systems' tendency to estimate hip joint centers farther from their true anatomical position than marker-based methods do.
  • Knee rotation and foot progression angle also showed comparatively weak agreement. Knee internal rotation (RMSE 9.13°, correlation 0.28) and foot internal progression (RMSE 7.61°, correlation 0.13) were both measures where the two systems' curves tracked together only loosely.
  • Smaller but consistent offsets appeared in several other measures. Pelvic anterior tilt (RMSE 5.73°), ankle inversion (RMSE 5.65°), and knee varus (RMSE 4.15°) showed offsets between systems without a full breakdown in agreement.

What This Means for Movement Science Researchers

For researchers weighing whether to adopt markerless capture for gait studies, this early comparison offers a useful baseline: Theia3D tracked closely with an established marker-based model for the sagittal-plane movements most central to everyday walking analysis, hip, knee, and ankle flexion, while transverse-plane rotations and foot progression remained the measures to treat with more caution. The authors frame this explicitly as a first step, intended to be followed by the same comparison in people with gait disorders and eventually extended to kinetics and upper-body kinematics as well.

The Role of Theia3D in Movement Analysis

In this study, Theia3D provided a markerless alternative for capturing lower-body 3D kinematics during overground walking trials in healthy adults and children, run simultaneously with the lab's existing marker-based system so the two could be compared directly, gait cycle by gait cycle, across the same walking trials.

Study Limitations and Future Directions

This summary is based on a brief conference abstract (ESMAC 2022 Abstract Book) rather than a full peer-reviewed journal article, so some methodological detail available in a full paper isn't available here, including a breakdown of how the RMSE and correlation values relate to specific movement phases within the gait cycle. One adult's data was excluded due to tracking artefacts, which further narrows an already small sample of 11 subjects split across two age groups. The authors explicitly frame this as an initial result, with the same comparison in a population with gait disorders, and an eventual extension to kinetics and upper-body kinematics, as their stated next steps; the pathological-gait extension has since been published as a separate study.

Citation: D'souza, S., Fohanno, V., & Schnell, S. (2022). Comparison of lower-body 3D gait kinematics between Theia3D markerless and the CAST model marker-based systems in healthy adults and children. Gait & Posture, 97, S332–S333 (ESMAC 2022 Abstract Book).

Link: Read the full study

Where Does Markerless Validation Start, and Where Should It Go Next?

This study shows one research group's deliberate first step: establishing agreement in healthy adults and children before testing a harder, more complex population. If your work involves evaluating markerless capture for gait research and you want to understand how a validation program like this one is typically built out, talk to our team about what that progression could look like for your own research questions.

Recent Posts