Sports Performance & Athlete Assessment
Qualisys Miqus

Comparison of 3-Dimensional Thorax and Upper-Extremity Joint Kinematics During Manual Wheelchair Propulsion Using Marker-Based and Markerless-Based Biomechanical Models

Journal of Applied Biomechanics
•
2026
•
Original research
Theia3D version:
Not specified in the paper
More Articles

Study at a glance

In 15 young adult full-time manual wheelchair users, Theia3D showed good agreement with marker-based motion capture for the shoulder and elbow movements most central to wheelchair propulsion, but showed substantial, systematic differences for shoulder and elbow rotation and for wrist motion, pointing to specific joints and planes where markerless upper-extremity measurement currently needs more caution in this population.

Summary

Disclaimer: The following summary details independent academic research. Theia3D is intended for research, sports performance and educational use only. It is not cleared as a medical device and is not intended to be used for the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of any disease, injury or medical condition.

Editor's note: this paper does not state a specific Theia3D software version in its methods.

Study Overview

Design

A prospective, cross-sectional, concurrent comparison study evaluating agreement between a marker-based biomechanical model and a novel markerless (Theia3D) biomechanical model for three-dimensional thorax segment and bilateral shoulder, elbow, and wrist joint kinematics during manual wheelchair propulsion.

Participants

Fifteen young adults (mean age 22.5 years), each a full-time manual wheelchair user living with a permanent physical disability affecting trunk or lower-extremity function for at least 12 months, representing a range of underlying conditions.

Data Collection

Participants were fitted with 34 reflective markers on the chest, back, and arms, then seated in their own personal manual wheelchair on a stationary, passive roller system. After a practice period, participants propelled their wheelchair using their own self-selected speed and propulsion style while a 12-camera Qualisys Miqus Hybrid motion capture system recorded simultaneously: 6 cameras captured 3D marker trajectories at 120 Hz for the marker-based model, and 6 cameras captured 2D video at 60 Hz, which was processed through Theia3D to generate the markerless model.

Analysis

Ten wheelchair propulsion cycles per participant were time-normalized and averaged for comparison between the two models. Statistical parametric mapping was used to identify portions of the propulsion cycle where thorax and bilateral upper-extremity joint angles and joint center positions differed significantly between the two models, and Pearson correlation coefficients and average root mean square differences (RMSD) were calculated to describe the strength and magnitude of agreement for each joint, segment, and plane of motion.

Key Findings

  • Shoulder flexion-extension, shoulder abduction, and elbow flexion-extension, the movements most central to the wheelchair propulsion stroke itself, showed the strongest agreement between the two models, with very strong correlations and comparatively smaller average differences (roughly 5 to 9 degrees).
  • Shoulder internal-external rotation and elbow forearm rotation (pronation-supination) showed the largest and most consistent differences between the two models, with average differences of roughly 27 to 37 degrees across both the right and left sides.
  • Wrist flexion-extension and side-to-side wrist motion also showed sizable, consistent offsets between the two models, averaging roughly 15 to 18 degrees, which the authors suggest may reflect known limitations in how current pose-estimation approaches handle smaller, more distal body segments like the hand and wrist.
  • Thorax forward-bending (flexion-extension) was significantly different between the two models, but the researchers identified a specific, likely explanation: Theia3D and the marker-based model defined the center of the chest segment using different anatomical references, resulting in a consistent positional offset that likely drove much of this particular difference, rather than reflecting a more fundamental tracking disagreement.
  • The authors describe the overall pattern as joint- and plane-dependent, with the strongest agreement for the primary movements driving wheelchair propulsion and the weakest agreement for rotational movements and the more distal wrist joint, and they are explicit that whether these differences are large enough to matter for a given specific use remains an open, use-dependent question.

What This Means for Movement Science Researchers and Wheelchair Mobility Assessment Teams

For researchers and assessment teams working with manual wheelchair users, this study offers a specific, nuanced picture rather than a simple yes-or-no answer: markerless motion capture showed strong agreement with marker-based measurement for the core movements that drive the propulsion stroke itself, supporting its potential as a faster, less technically demanding way to study these specific measures in a population where marker-based setup can be especially challenging. At the same time, the substantial, consistent differences found for shoulder and forearm rotation and for wrist motion specifically are an important, concrete caution: teams whose work depends on precise measurement of these particular rotational or wrist-specific movements, relevant given the documented association between wrist mechanics and wrist-related discomfort in this population, should weigh this finding carefully before relying on markerless measurement alone for those specific joints and planes. The authors' own framing, that the right choice between marker-based and markerless motion analysis depends on which specific joints, planes, and overall goals matter most for a given application, is a practical, useful way for teams to think through this decision for their own work.

The Role of Theia3D in Movement Analysis

Theia3D was the markerless motion capture system directly evaluated against a marker-based biomechanical model in this study, specifically for its ability to measure thorax and bilateral upper-extremity kinematics during manual wheelchair propulsion in a population not previously studied with this technology. The study's identification of a specific, well-explained source of thorax disagreement, a difference in how each model defines the chest segment's anatomical center, rather than a general tracking failure, offers a useful, concrete example of how markerless validation research can trace a measurement difference back to a specific, addressable methodological source rather than treating all disagreement as an unexplained limitation of the underlying technology.

Study Limitations and Future Directions

The authors note that their sample consisted of relatively young, lean, and physically active manual wheelchair users recruited by convenience, which limited their ability to explore how agreement between the two models might differ across a wider range of ages and body types. Testing was conducted while participants propelled on a stationary roller system, chosen to optimize camera setup and keep participants positioned consistently within the capture volume, so these findings may not directly extend to more ecologically realistic conditions such as overground wheelchair propulsion, which the authors identify as an important direction for future replication. The filtering and smoothing approaches used to process data differed somewhat between the two models, which may have contributed to some of the observed differences, although the magnitude of disagreement found here was consistent with prior related research despite this methodological difference. The authors also analyzed their data at the participant level, using one averaged value per person rather than each individual trial, a choice intended to meet a statistical independence requirement that may have reduced the resolution of the comparison. They identify replicating this work during overground wheelchair propulsion, testing a broader and more diverse group of wheelchair users, and further investigating the specific sources of disagreement in joint center positions and joint angles as important next steps.

Citation: Moon, J., Tran, D. F., Lopez, J. R., & Hanks, M. M. (2026). Comparison of 3-dimensional thorax and upper-extremity joint kinematics during manual wheelchair propulsion using marker-based and markerless-based biomechanical models. Journal of Applied Biomechanics. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1123/jab.2025-0104

Link: Read the full study

Does Markerless Motion Capture Accurately Measure Upper-Extremity Motion During Wheelchair Propulsion?

This study of 15 manual wheelchair users finds that Theia3D shows strong agreement with marker-based motion capture for the shoulder and elbow movements most central to the propulsion stroke, with larger, more consistent differences for shoulder and forearm rotation and for wrist motion specifically. If your work involves wheelchair mobility or upper-extremity movement assessment, talk to our team about where Theia3D currently stands for this kind of application.

Recent Posts